THE SOURCING DIRECTORY
Choose a practical Madison-area sourcing trip: everyday thrift, selected vintage fashion, Middleton consignment, furniture and salvage, or two outlet stops. Start with one cluster and leave time to inspect and list what you buy. Nine editable shortlists keep these different shopping models separate.
Plan a trip with these shops ↓Use Add to trip on the local store cards or map pins, then open My trip to arrange your stops.
Browse every location Read the local shopping guide ↓Open local mapChoose a trip (9)CHOOSE YOUR KIND OF SOURCING DAY
Madison is not one walkable thrift circuit. Compare nearby shops with similar merchandise before crossing town. New profiles were reviewed online; older profiles retain their own check dates. Current reduced-hours notices for St. Vinny's Stoughton and Waunakee are noted below and reflected in their profiles.
The Junction Road Agrace, Watts Road Humane Society shop and Odana Road St. Vinny's make a useful clothing-and-housewares comparison. Goodwill West and Pink Poodle add different pricing models nearby. Selected designer resale should not be treated as donation-thrift pricing.
Simply Savvy mixes apparel and furniture; The Cozy Home concentrates on furnishings; Yada mixes resale and new fair-trade goods. RTC adds estate and consigned antiques but has limited source-listed hours. A Friday comparison fits the recorded schedules; call RTC because expanded hours were planned, not confirmed.
Stillgood's buys designer, contemporary and vintage clothing outright, while Good Style Shop brings together independent vintage vendors. Add the existing Williamson Street St. Vinny's to compare models. Stillgood's is closed Tuesday, and Good Style's exact daily times were not confirmed; check before setting off.
The East Towne Goodwill, east Agrace and east Humane Society are separate retail addresses. Farther south, The Cozy Home Monona and ReStore East focus on furnishings. Antiques Mall of Madison and Deconstruction add dealer goods and salvage rather than low-cost clothing racks.
Verona and Sun Prairie each have Goodwill and St. Vinny's comparisons. Stoughton adds The Next Generation's children's resale and women's consignment. Do not combine all three towns into a short outing. St. Vinny's Stoughton currently lists Mon-Sat 11am-6pm and Sun 10am-5pm; Waunakee lists Mon-Fri 11am-6pm and weekends 10am-5pm under reduced-hours notices. Their profiles now reflect these temporary schedules.
The Cozy Home Cambridge is at 424 West Main Street, with daily 10am-5pm retail hours. This is a separate drive east, not a stop to add automatically to a Madison half-day. The county rooftop point matches the owner street address; consignment intake remains at Monona by approval and appointment.
Hello Art Hatchery at 134 East Main Street sells secondhand and some new art and craft supplies. The Next Generation is nearby at 161 East Main for clothing resale; Goodwill is a separate Highway 51 drive. Call Hello Art Hatchery before a special trip. Second Chance Thrift remains off these routes while its pin is unresolved.
START WITH A SHORTLIST
These are starting points, not timed or optimized routes. Check each shop’s current hours, then change the order or remove stops. Opening a shortlist does not replace your saved trip.
Compare clothing and household resale at Agrace West, DCHS West and St. Vinny's Odana. Use their distinct retail addresses and leave time to inspect condition.
Tuesday-Saturday: source-listed hours overlap 11am-5pm. Agrace does not list Sunday retail hours.
Open west-side thrift shortlistStart with Yada, compare Simply Savvy, then focus on home furnishings at The Cozy Home. New and resale merchandise are mixed at these shops.
Tuesday, Thursday-Saturday: 11am-5pm overlap. Yada is closed Wednesday/Sunday and Simply Savvy Monday/Sunday. RTC is an optional Friday/Saturday stop after calling.
Open Middleton resale shortlistCompare donated-goods thrift at St. Vinny's with Stillgood's selected buy-sell-trade clothing. Good Style is a separate optional East Johnson stop after confirming its exact opening hours.
Monday and Wednesday-Sunday: 11am-5pm overlap. Stillgood's is closed Tuesday; its buying counter stops at 4:30pm.
Open Williamson Street shortlistCompare Goodwill East Towne, Agrace East and DCHS East. Each is a separate store with different inventory; this is a driving shortlist, not a single shopping center.
Tuesday-Saturday: 11am-5pm shared window based on reviewed retail schedules.
Open east-side thrift shortlistTry St. Vinny's Dig & Save and Goodwill's Tradesmen Drive outlet. They are separate driving stops. Compare condition, category rules and your actual total rather than assuming identical pricing.
Daily: 10am-5pm fits both listed retail schedules. Dig & Save weighs clothing and small miscellaneous categories but prices some bulky goods and electronics individually; confirm current rules at each shop.
Open outlets shortlistCompare Pink Poodle's selected apparel with ReStore West and Atomic Antiques for furnishings and objects. Inspect large purchases and arrange transport. Atomic's owner sites disagree on ZIP; use the recorded Verona Road street address and confirm directions.
Tuesday-Saturday: 11am-5pm overlap. ReStore donation drop-off ends at 3pm, earlier than retail closing.
Open Odana and Verona Road shortlistCompare the two Verona shops, then add Fitchburg Goodwill if you have time for a separate drive. Brand-network labels describe affiliation, not corporate ownership.
Monday-Saturday: 10am-7pm overlap. Sunday: 10am-5pm overlap. Check holiday exceptions.
Open Verona and Fitchburg shortlistCompare Goodwill on McCoy Road with St. Vinny's on West Main Street. Keep it as a two-stop trip or add east Madison only if time and buying budget permit.
Monday-Saturday: 10am-7pm overlap. Sunday: 10am-5pm overlap. Retail access does not guarantee buying or donation acceptance.
Open Sun Prairie shortlistStart with Hello Art Hatchery for secondhand craft, sewing and art supplies, compare The Next Generation for children's resale and women's consignment, then add Goodwill. Art supplies are a separate sourcing category from apparel.
Tuesday-Friday: noon-5pm shared retail window. Saturday: 10am-5pm. Hello Art Hatchery warns that a small shop may close unexpectedly; call before a special trip. St. Vinny's is an optional additional stop under its reduced-hours schedule.
Open Stoughton shortlistIn Stoughton, The Next Generation lists Tuesday-Friday noon-5pm and Saturday 10am-5pm. Goodwill can be a later stop. St. Vinny's has a reduced-hours notice; its current source schedule is Mon-Sat 11am-6pm, Sun 10am-5pm. Waunakee also has reduced hours. Check the linked operator pages for any subsequent staffing or holiday changes.
Cambridge Cozy Home is an optional separate-town furniture stop, open daily 10am-5pm per the operator. Midwest Vintage 608 uses ZIP 53719 from the county address record; the tourism page still shows 53711. Upshift is not included because its street number remains inconsistent across sources.
Pink Poodle has a dated August intake notice, so call before bringing consignment. Cozy Home consignment intake is at Monona only after photo approval and appointment. Shopping hours and intake hours are separate.
No shop has been personally visited for this guide. Unknown fitting rooms, step-free access, returns or loading help remain unknown. Use the source links and call when those details determine whether the trip works.
Choose the shopping model and side of town that fit your inventory. West/east thrift trips compare donated-goods stores; Middleton and Odana add selected resale; outlets take more sorting time. Nine shortlists are starting points, not optimized driving routes.
No. Dig & Save and Goodwill Outlet are separate outlet stops. Ordinary thrift, consignment, curated vintage, antique malls and salvage are different shopping models with different prices and category rules.
Confirm intake first. Cozy Home requires photo approval and Monona appointments, Pink Poodle may pause intake, and Stillgood's uses buying hours and selection criteria. Retail opening alone does not establish acceptance.
FROM SOURCING TO SELLING
Use realistic sold comparisons, condition, fees and shipping to decide how much you can spend. Keep a reserve for packaging and slower inventory.
Keep purchase cost, material tags, measurements, flaws and photos connected to the same item identifier.
Leave time to process and list the purchases. More stops only help when the inventory can move through your workflow.
Keep planning with the free profit calculator, condition-notes guide and printable sourcing checklist. Clothing sellers can also use the research library before buying.
Guide sources reviewed October 17, 2026: St. Vinny’s - Williamson Street - Madison, WI · St. Vinny’s - Odana Road - Madison, WI · St. Vinny’s - Dig & Save Outlet - Madison, WI · St. Vinny’s - Waunakee - Waunakee, WI · St. Vinny’s - Verona - Verona, WI · St. Vinny’s - Stoughton - Stoughton, WI · St. Vinny’s - Sun Prairie - Sun Prairie, WI · Agrace Thrift - Madison West - Madison, WI · Agrace Thrift - Madison East - Madison, WI · Agrace Thrift - Home Store - Madison, WI · Dane County Humane Society Thrift - West - Madison, WI · Dane County Humane Society Thrift - East - Madison, WI · Boomerangs Resale Store - Madison, WI · Goodwill - Monona - Monona, WI · Goodwill - Nakoma - Madison, WI · Goodwill - Madison Northside - Madison, WI · Goodwill - Middleton - Middleton, WI · Goodwill - Fitchburg - Fitchburg, WI · Goodwill - Madison West - Madison, WI · Goodwill - Madison Outlet Store - Madison, WI · Goodwill - Madison East Towne - Madison, WI · Goodwill - Verona - Verona, WI · Goodwill - Sun Prairie - Sun Prairie, WI · Goodwill - Stoughton - Stoughton, WI · Yada Fair Trade & Resale - Middleton, WI · Simply Savvy - Middleton, WI · The Cozy Home - Middleton - Middleton, WI · The Cozy Home - Monona - Monona, WI · Stillgood's - Madison, WI · Good Style Shop - Madison, WI · RTC Estate Sales & Consignment - Middleton, WI · The Pink Poodle - Madison, WI · The Next Generation - Stoughton, WI · Habitat ReStore - Madison West - Madison, WI · Habitat ReStore - Madison East - Madison, WI · Antiques Mall of Madison - Madison, WI · Deconstruction Inc. - Madison, WI · Atomic Antiques - Madison, WI · The Cozy Home - Cambridge - Cambridge, WI · Midwest Vintage 608 - Madison, WI · Hello Art Hatchery - Stoughton, WI. This is an online source review, not a firsthand visit. Store profiles retain their own check dates.
YOUR SOURCING DAY
Add up to 20 stops, then use Move up / Move down to set your order. Check shopping hours before heading out. Directions follow your order; they do not optimize it.
Between-stop straight-line distances use approximate map pins. Rough driving ranges assume roads add 20–60% distance, with 20–35 mph for legs under 15 straight-line miles and 35–55 mph for longer legs. These are planning assumptions, not calculated road routes. Rivers, road layouts, traffic and parking can make actual travel much longer. Excludes your journey to the first stop, return home and shopping time. Check the route and current timing in Google Maps.
Your trip is empty. Choose “Add to trip” on a store card or map pin.
Longer trips open in groups of four stops so every stop is included on phones. Your saved trip stays in this browser and does not sync across devices. In private/incognito browsing, it is removed when you close the private session. Copy the share link to keep a portable version. A shared link contains only public store IDs.
Independent / local shop
1946 S Stoughton Road, Madison, WI
Mon-Sat 10am-5pm; Sunday not listed
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
2402 E Springs Drive, Madison, WI
Mon-Sat 10am-5pm; Sunday not listed
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
118 Junction Road, Madison, WI
Mon-Sat 10am-5pm; Sunday not listed
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
4748 Cottage Grove Rd, Madison, WI 53716
Mon-Wed/Fri 10am-6pm; Thu 10am-8pm; Sat 10am-5pm; Sun 11am-5pm.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
4546 Verona Rd, Madison, WI
Daily 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
1133 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI
Tue-Fri 10am-6pm; Sat 10am-4pm; closed Sun-Mon
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
5231 High Crossing Blvd, Madison, WI 53718
Tue-Sat 11am-7pm; Sun-Mon 11am-5pm
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
6904 Watts Road, Madison, WI 53719
Tue-Sat 11am-7pm; Sun-Mon 11am-5pm
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
1010 Walsh Rd, Madison, WI 53714
Thu-Fri 10am-6pm; Sat 10am-2pm; other days not listed.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
817 E Johnson St, Madison, WI 53703
Open daily; exact opening and closing times not confirmed. Check before traveling.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
6291 McKee Rd, Fitchburg, WI 53719
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
2127 East Springs Drive, Madison, WI 53704
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
2901 North Sherman Ave, Madison, WI 53704
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
5525 Tradesmen Drive, Madison, WI 53718
Mon-Sat 9am-7pm; Sun 9am-5pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
7475 Mineral Point Road, Madison, WI 53717
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
6280 Century Ave, Middleton, WI 53562
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
2501 Royal Ave, Monona, WI 53713
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
4530 Verona Rd., Madison, WI 53711
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
1780 US-51, Stoughton, WI 53589
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
2111 McCoy Rd, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
118 South Main Street, Verona, WI 53593
Mon-Sat 9am-8pm; Sun 10am-6pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
4207 Monona Dr, Madison, WI 53716
Tue-Sat 9am-5pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
6201 Odana Rd, Madison, WI 53719
Tue-Sat 9am-5pm.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
134 E Main St, Stoughton, WI 53589
Mon 11am-3pm; Tue-Sat 10am-5pm; Sun closed. Call ahead for a special trip.
Get directions ↗No stores match these filters. Select another layer, broaden your search, or clear the filters.
A source check date records when a source page was reviewed. It is not a live opening status or a guarantee of inventory. Operator type is shown only when recorded or identifiable from a network brand; other entries remain unclassified. Closure notices are hidden until you choose to include them.
Open a city to browse its complete list. These links stay available while you use the filters and map above. A listed shop may have a closure notice; read its profile before planning a visit.
Madison & Dane County sourcing guide ↗