THE SOURCING DIRECTORY
Build a north-of-Milwaukee sourcing day around donated-goods thrift, Cedarburg vintage and home resale, or selected designer fashion. These nine reviewed locations include an optional Thiensville extension. Pick one of 3 shortlists and leave time to inspect what you buy.
Plan a trip with these shops ↓Use Add to trip on the local store cards or map pins, then open My trip to arrange your stops.
Browse every location Read the local shopping guide ↓Open local mapChoose a trip (3)CHOOSE YOUR KIND OF SOURCING DAY
A donation-thrift day and a curated vintage day serve different budgets. The lists below distinguish those shopping models, show useful opening windows and keep buying-counter rules separate from retail access.
These suggested trips are not active because one or more stops need confirmed shopping hours or visit access. Their shop profiles remain available in the local directory; confirm each stop before making your own trip.
Family Sharing and Goodwill offer a clothing, books and household-goods comparison. Family Sharing is a local nonprofit supporting its pantry; Goodwill is a regional brand-network store. The owner currently lists Family Sharing Tuesday-Saturday, 10am-4pm, superseding older directory hours.
Dime a Dance is upstairs at Cedar Creek Settlement and carries vintage fashion, jewelry and antiques. Ivana's new Cedarburg Square address is W62N248 Washington Avenue, suite 103; some links on its own site still point to its previous location. Corner Closet is another mixed new/consigned clothing option, but call for its unconfirmed hours before adding it.
St. Vincent de Paul is a separate street-address stop on Highway C; Hidden Treasure is downtown on West Grand Avenue. FIFTH-MAIN on North Franklin adds curated preowned designer fashion. Its Thursday-Sunday winter schedule is narrower than its summer opening days.
FIFTH-MAIN's second boutique is at 174 South Main Street in Thiensville. This is a separate drive south, rather than part of a Cedarburg walking route. The buying counter is only here and currently pauses appointments because of overstock.
START WITH A SHORTLIST
These are starting points, not timed or optimized routes. Check each shop’s current hours, then change the order or remove stops. Opening a shortlist does not replace your saved trip.
Compare Family Sharing, Grafton Goodwill and St. Vincent de Paul. Start with the categories you sell rather than expecting every shop to have the same price level or inventory. These are separate driving stops.
Tuesday-Saturday: recorded retail hours overlap 10am-4pm. Family Sharing is closed Sunday/Monday; do not use pantry or donation schedules as shop opening hours.
Open donation thrift shortlistBrowse Dime a Dance for vintage clothing and objects, Ivana's for furniture and home accessories, then FIFTH-MAIN Port Washington for selected fashion. Use Ivana's new address and allow travel time between Cedarburg and Port Washington.
Thursday-Friday: noon-5pm overlap. Saturday: 11am-4pm. Sunday: noon-4pm. These days fit both listed FIFTH-MAIN seasons; confirm holiday and construction exceptions. Dime a Dance is upstairs, so ask about access when needed.
Open vintage and resale shortlistCompare FIFTH-MAIN Thiensville with Family Sharing and Grafton Goodwill. Check garment condition, materials, exact style and sold comparables across different pricing models.
Tuesday-Saturday: 10am-4pm overlap, limited by Family Sharing. This is a driving route. FIFTH-MAIN buying is paused; a shopping visit does not imply intake is available.
Open fashion comparison shortlistThese are proposed source-reviewed trips, not firsthand recommendations or promises of inventory. Check current hours before a dedicated drive.
Corner Closet is deliberately optional until its weekly schedule is confirmed. Hidden Treasure's Saturday discrepancy remains visible instead of being converted into a guessed closing time.
For bulky goods, confirm loading help, measurements and vehicle capacity before paying. Do not assume returns, fitting rooms or step-free access when a profile does not confirm them.
No. Cedarburg has clustered shops, but Grafton, Port Washington and Thiensville are separate destinations. Use the chosen shortlist and directions instead of treating the whole guide as a walking circuit.
Thursday-Friday fit the recorded thrift and winter FIFTH-MAIN schedules. Saturday also works when Hidden Treasure comes early. Family Sharing is closed Sunday/Monday; check each profile before substituting stops.
Retail opening does not establish buying availability. FIFTH-MAIN currently pauses appointments; Ivana's reviews consignment suitability. Read the shop's current intake rules before bringing goods.
FROM SOURCING TO SELLING
Use expected sale price, condition, fees and shipping to set a maximum buy cost. Keep money for packaging and slower-selling inventory.
Record materials, measurements, flaws and purchase cost. Keep a consistent item identifier so research and photos stay connected.
Choose a manageable stop list and leave time for inspection, photographs and listings. A fuller vehicle only helps when the inventory gets processed.
Keep planning with the free profit calculator, condition-notes guide and printable sourcing checklist. Clothing sellers can also use the research library before buying.
Guide sources reviewed October 17, 2026: Goodwill - Grafton - Grafton, WI · Ivana's Trunk - Cedarburg, WI · Hidden Treasure Resale Shop - Port Washington, WI · Family Sharing Resale Boutique - Grafton, WI · St. Vincent de Paul - Ozaukee County - Port Washington, WI · FIFTH-MAIN - Port Washington - Port Washington, WI · FIFTH-MAIN - Thiensville - Thiensville, WI · Dime a Dance - Cedarburg, WI · Corner Closet - Cedarburg, WI. This is an online source review, not a firsthand visit. Store profiles retain their own check dates.
YOUR SOURCING DAY
Add up to 20 stops, then use Move up / Move down to set your order. Check shopping hours before heading out. Directions follow your order; they do not optimize it.
Between-stop straight-line distances use approximate map pins. Rough driving ranges assume roads add 20–60% distance, with 20–35 mph for legs under 15 straight-line miles and 35–55 mph for longer legs. These are planning assumptions, not calculated road routes. Rivers, road layouts, traffic and parking can make actual travel much longer. Excludes your journey to the first stop, return home and shopping time. Check the route and current timing in Google Maps.
Your trip is empty. Choose “Add to trip” on a store card or map pin.
Longer trips open in groups of four stops so every stop is included on phones. Your saved trip stays in this browser and does not sync across devices. In private/incognito browsing, it is removed when you close the private session. Copy the share link to keep a portable version. A shared link contains only public store IDs.
Independent / local shop
W63N655 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012
Current weekly shopping hours are not confirmed by the reviewed chamber profile; call before visiting.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
N70 W6340 Bridge Rd, Cedarburg, WI 53012
Mon-Sat 10am-5pm; Sun 11am-5pm.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
1002 Overland Ct, Grafton, WI 53024
Tue-Sat 10am-4pm; Sun-Mon closed.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
118 N Franklin St, Port Washington, WI 53074
Winter: Thu-Sat 10am-5pm, Sun 10am-4pm. Summer adds Tue-Wed 10am-5pm. Confirm seasonal changeover.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
174 S Main St, Thiensville, WI 53092
Tue-Sat 10am-6pm; other days not listed, confirm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
1715 Wisconsin Ave., Grafton, WI 53024
Mon: 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM; Tue: 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM; Wed: 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM; Thu: 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM; Fri: 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM; Sat: 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM; Sun: 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
139 W Grand Ave, Port Washington, WI
Mon-Fri 10am-5pm; Sunday closed. Saturday closing conflicts: homepage 3pm, Shop page 2pm; call before a Saturday visit.
Get directions ↗Independent / local shop
W62N248 Washington Ave, Suite 103, Cedarburg, WI 53012
Mon-Fri noon-5pm; Sat 11am-4pm; Sun noon-4pm.
Get directions ↗Chain or network affiliation
2673 Hwy C, Port Washington, WI 53074
Mon-Thu 9am-6pm; Fri-Sat 9am-5pm. Sunday hours not listed; confirm before visiting.
Get directions ↗No stores match these filters. Select another layer, broaden your search, or clear the filters.
A source check date records when a source page was reviewed. It is not a live opening status or a guarantee of inventory. Operator type is shown only when recorded or identifiable from a network brand; other entries remain unclassified. Closure notices are hidden until you choose to include them.
Open a city to browse its complete list. These links stay available while you use the filters and map above. A listed shop may have a closure notice; read its profile before planning a visit.
Milwaukee, Waukesha, Racine & Kenosha sourcing guide ↗ Cedarburg, Grafton & Port Washington sourcing guide ↗